Were These the Whitest Oscar Nominations Ever?
Is Spike Lee right? And David Oyelowo? Do the Academy Awards have a diversity problem? Editor at large Lynn Hirschberg tackles the 2016 nominations in W‘s podcast.
Since the Oscar nominations were announced, a controversy has overtaken the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences over the apparently consistent exclusion of minority and black actors in the awards’ acting categories. Again this year, like in 2015, all of the actors up for awards are white. As a result, director Spike Lee and actress Jada Pinket Smith have said they won’t attend the ceremony on February 28 at the Dolby Theater. And David Oyelowo, who was snubbed last year for his performance in Selma, described this year’s omissions as “unforgivable” in a speech on Monday night honoring the Academy’s president, Cheryl Boone Isaacs. So, how bad was the problem this year? Were there no credible candidates for nominations? Is there merit to the hashtag #OscarsSoWhite?
“It was by far the whitest Oscar nominations I can recall in recent memory. It is as lily white as they come.” That’s editor at large Lynn Hirschberg speaking in W‘s podcast, available to listen below and for subscription on iTunes. Hirschberg goes on to say that there were scores of strong contenders that were inexplicably overlooked: Straight Outta Compton, Mya Taylor in Tangerine, and Michael B. Jordan in Creed.
Instead, the only person to be nominated from Jordan’s critically acclaimed and commercially successful film was – drumbeat – Sylvester Stallone.
“Stallone couldn’t get arrested a month ago, days ago even, and now Sylvester Stallone is the frontrunner for Best Supporting actor,” Hirschberg says. “I find that narrative both delightful and so Hollywood. They love a comeback and they love a comeback in something they already know. I mean, how many times has he played Rocky Balboa? The man has been in the desert. He’s been, in a cosmic sense, Leo [DiCaprio] in The Revenant. He’s been mauled by bears, and now he will have his moment.”
Hirschberg also tackles the absence of Star Wars from the nominations, the man crushes among the Best Actor nominees, and why Brie Larson is likely to walk away an Oscar winner.
Best Performances
Rooney Mara on the cover of W’s February 2016 issue.
Watch a video interview with Rooney Mara
Rooney Mara wears Hermès jacket; Maison Margiela shirt. Beauty: Lancôme.
Hair by Odile Gilbert. Makeup by Stéphane Marais.
Carey Mulligan on the cover of W’s February 2016 issue.
Watch a video interview with Carey Mulligan
Carey Mulligan wears Prada jacket, sweater vest, and neck piece; Anita Ko earring. Beauty: Dior.
Hair by Odile Gilbert. Makeup by Stéphane Marais.
Brie Larson on the cover of W’s February 2016 issue.
Brie Larson wears Marc Jacobs gown. Beauty: Marc Jacobs Beauty.
Watch a video interview with Brie Larson
Hair by Odile Gilbert. Makeup by Stéphane Marais.
Saoirse Ronan on the cover of W’s February 2016 issue.
Watch a video interview with Saoirse Ronan
Saoirse Ronan wears Chanel top; Mikimoto earrings. Beauty: Chanel.
Hair by Odile Gilbert. Makeup by Stéphane Marais.
Alicia Vikander on the cover of W’s February 2016 issue.
Watch a video interview with Alicia Vikander
Alicia Vikander wears Louis Vuitton vest and jumpsuit. Beauty: Nars.
Hair and makeup by Martin Cullen for Bumble and bumble at Streeters, Mary Greenwell for Chanel at Premier Hair and Make-up.
Eddie Redmayne on the cover of W’s February 2016 issue.
Watch a video interview with Eddie Redmayne
Eddie Redmayne wears Burberry peacoat and T-shirt. Grooming: Burberry.
Grooming for Eddie Redmayne by Petra Sellge for Elemis. Manicures by Michelle Saunders for Essie at Forward Artists, Adam Slee for Rimmel London at Streeters.
Saoirse Ronan in Brooklyn
“I was scared every single day on Brooklyn. I mean, you always get jitters, and you always get a little nervous before you do your first take, but there was something about shooting at home, so close to where I grew up. I was terrified.”
Watch a video interview with Saoirse Ronan
Vera Wang Collection dress and bandeau; Chopard earrings.
Michael Caine in Youth
“Youth was a complete surprise to me. My agent rang and said, ‘The director Paolo Sorrentino, who just won the Oscar for best foreign film, is sending you a script.’ I said, ‘Does he know who I am?’ She said, ‘Yes! He wrote this script for you.’ I nearly said, ‘You don’t have to send the script; I’ll do it for nothing,’ but I stayed cool and said, ‘I’ll be happy to read it.’ ”
Watch a video interview with Michael Caine
Boss jacket and shirt.
Cate Blanchett in Carol
“All my life I’ve been playing dress-up, and now I get to do it for a living. In film, particularly, the costumes are a big part of my characters. When I first appear in Carol, in a fur coat, hat, and gloves, the audience immediately ascribes meaning to the person I’m playing. A certain scarf or handbag or a pair of glasses can reveal multitudes about someone’s persona.”
Watch a video interview with Cate Blanchett
Givenchy by Riccardo Tisci dress.
Jennifer Jason Leigh in The Hateful Eight and Anomalisa
“I based part of my Hateful Eight character on Regan from The Exorcist. After she kills the priest, she doesn’t know what to do with her power. But she’s also completely lost—full of adrenaline and like an animal. Quentin Tarantino picked up on this right away. You can’t get any film reference past him.”
Watch a video interview with Jennifer Jason Leigh
Rochas dress; Agent Provocateur bra; Chanel Fine Jewelry bracelet.
Samuel L. Jackson in The Hateful Eight
“I like being a villain. It’s fun to be unapologetically bad. I hate movies where the bad guy starts to say he’s sorry and explains why he’s doing bad stuff. I like to play men who say, ‘Look—this is just what I do.’ ”
Watch a video interview with Samuel L. Jackson
Giorgio Armani sweater. Grooming by Autumn Moultrie for Dior at Exclusive Artists Management.
Amy Schumer in Trainwreck
“I have a crush on Christian Bale. Newsies was a really big deal to me. I haven’t watched it in a while, but maybe I’d still feel attracted to 15-year- old Christian. I definitely wanted to have sex with him when he was emaciated in The Machinist. I’ll take Christian any way I can get him.”
Giorgio Armani jacket; Julianne shorts from Journelle, New York; Wolford tights; Hermès shoes. Styled by Sarah M Richardson.
Watch a video interview with Richard Gere
Richard Gere wears Giorgio Armani coat, suit, shirt, belt, and shoes. Styled by Sarah M Richardson. Grooming by Birgitte for Acqua di Parma at Sally Harlor.
Richard Gere in Time Out of Mind.
“While I was in character as a homeless man, I would panhandle, and I was very bad at it. We shot for 42 minutes straight, and in that time, I made less than a buck and a half. No one recognized me or made eye contact with me. Their brains went ‘homeless guy’ from two blocks away, and they decided, ‘I don’t want to give to him.’ ”
Watch a video interview with Richard Gere
Giorgio Armani coat, suit, shirt, belt, and shoes. Styled by Sarah M Richardson. Grooming by Birgitte for Acqua di Parma at Sally Harlor.
Bryan Cranston in Trumbo
“I’ve been in drag for several TV roles, and I make the ugliest woman in the world. As a man, I am not vain. But when brilliant makeup artists are making me into a woman, I become very concerned with my looks. ‘Can you soften my jaw?…Can you do anything about the wrinkles?’ Sadly, it’s a lost cause.”
Watch a video interview with Bryan Cranston
Burberry trenchcoat; Balenciaga shirt.
Carey Mulligan in Suffragette and Far From the Madding Crowd
“I don’t know if I believe in chemistry on a film. I know loads of people who’ve had quite sexy onscreen relationships with people they hate. I think chemistry might just be actors doing their jobs well.”
Watch a video interview with Carey Mulligan
Chanel blouse, dress, and bag; Anita Ko earring.
Charlize Theron in Mad Max: Fury Road.
“My character Imperator Furiosa, in Mad Max: Fury Road, is missing an arm, but in the film we never explain how that happened—she just is. I don’t think the character would have the same gravitas if she wasn’t broken like that. Instead, she’s an entire human being who just happens to be an amputee.”
Watch a video interview with Charlize Theron
Dior Fine Jewelry ring. Styled by Sarah M Richardson. Hair by Enzo Angileri for Infusium 23 at Cloutier Remix; makeup by Francesca Tolot for Dior at Cloutier Remix.
Elizabeth Banks in Love & Mercy
“At auditions, I was the type of person to dress for the part. Then a casting director told me, ‘Don’t dress like the character; just look as gorgeous as possible all the time.’ So then I realized, if you’re up for the part of a waitress, put on an apron over something you might wear to the Oscars. That’s when I started getting roles.”
Watch a video interview with Elizabeth Banks
Saint Laurent by Hedi Slimane dress; Graff earrings; Bulgari bracelet.
Benicio Del Toro in Sicario
“At my 4th birthday party, I wore an astronaut costume and we had a cake shaped like a rocket. I remember being very excited about dressing up like someone else. That may have been the beginning of my acting career.”
Watch a video interview with Benicio Del Toro
Olatz pajamas.
Alicia Vikander in Ex Machina, Testament of Youth, The Man From U.N.C.L.E., and The Danish Girl
“I was on a long-haul flight at night, and as I went down the aisle to the bathroom, I counted at least 14 screens that had Ex Machina on. I was walking past myself playing Ava, the android. I was tempted to go to the front of the cabin and look over my shoulder to the people watching her. I thought it would shock them to find Ava on their plane. There might have been screams.”
Watch a video interview with Alicia Vikander
Louis Vuitton vest. Styled by Sarah M Richardson. Hair by Martin Cullen for Bumble and bumble at Streeters; makeup by Mary Greenwell for Chanel at Premier Hair and Make-up.
Joel Edgerton in The Gift and Black Mass
“I’ve never counted how many times I’ve died in movies. I’ve been shot on many, many occasions. I find dying easy. The hard part is trying to hold your breath, because, obviously, dead people don’t breathe. One of these days, I’d love to do a long, melodramatic, triple-death ending. It would be like a drum solo at the end of a rock song. You think the song is over, and then it kicks in again.”
Watch a video interview with Joel Edgerton
Coach jacket; Simon Miller T-shirt; A.P.C. jeans; The Frye Company boots.
Watch a video interview with Joel Edgerton
Joel Edgerton wears Coach jacket; Simon Miller T-shirt.
Brie Larson in Room
“I have always wanted to act. When I was around 7 I started auditioning, and I recall going up for a fish-sticks commercial. By then, I was completely committed to the craft of acting and had memorized a full monologue. The director was only looking for cute kids and wasn’t interested in hearing my speech. I started sobbing. ‘They won’t let me act!’ I wailed to my mother.”
Watch a video interview with Brie Larson
Giorgio Armani coat.
Paul Dano in Love & Mercy and Youth
“I gained 30 pounds to play the Beach Boys’ Brian Wilson in Love & Mercy. When I showed up for my costume fitting, the director looked at me and said, ‘Um…I think you could lose a few pounds.’ I was so upset. I’m naturally a skinny guy, and it was not fun gaining that weight.”
Watch a video interview with Paul Dano
Maison Margiela suit; Giorgio Armani shirt; Calvin Klein White Label tie.
Peter Sarsgaard in Experimenter
“In college, I was hot for a girl and took an acting class to be near her. They had me do a role from a play called Bent. The scene was between two gay men during the Holocaust, and I felt enormous empathy from the people in the room who were watching. It was very seductive: In that instant, I fell in love with acting.”
Watch a video interview with Peter Sarsgaard
Balenciaga jacket and shirt. Styled by Sarah M Richardson.
Jacob Tremblay in Room
“When people watch my movie, they cry. My mom told me that it was a very dark subject, so I didn’t read the whole script. But after we saw Room the first time, my mom was crying. People were a mess. Their mascara was falling off.”
Sogoodnight pajamas; Worth & Worth by Orlando Palacios hat.
Greta Gerwig in Mistress America
“My character, Brooke, is both a fraud and the genuine article, which is, I think, the truth: People can be both. To get anything done, you need a lot of crazy.”
Watch a video interview with Greta Gerwig
Gap T-shirt; J Brand jeans. Styled by Sarah M Richardson.
Jake Gyllenhaal in Southpaw and Everest
“I had no idea how to box before Southpaw. In an early sparring session, I got hit in the face and then in the body, and that first body shot dropped me. In my work, I try to get into the real space of my characters, but at that moment, I thought, What the hell am I doing this for?”
Watch a video interview with Jake Gyllenhaal
Dior Homme jacket; Alternative T-shirt.
Mya Taylor in Tangerine. “Tangerine happened for me because I was in the right place at the right time. A very attractive person named Sean Baker walked up to me at the LGBT center in Hollywood, and we started talking. Our conversations about hustling and struggling with my gender transition became the basis for the movie.”
Watch a video interview with Mya Taylor
Adrienne Landau stole; Rosamosario bra; Tom Ford skirt; Nina Runsdorf earrings and cuff; Chanel belt; Manolo Blahnik clutch and pumps; Wolford stay-ups; Cornelia James gloves (on bed).
Jane Fonda in Youth
“On my 75th birthday—which was my favorite birthday—I had 150 people to my house, including several ex-husbands. It was December 21, 2012, which was, according to the Mayan calendar, the day there would be a major shift to a new paradigm and the world would change. I can’t say that I experienced any sort of turning point, but I had a good time. And the ex-husbands all got along.”
Watch a video interview with Jane Fonda
Salvatore Ferragamo coat; Vhernier ring. Hair by Matthew Shields; makeup by Elan Bongiorno at Exclusive Artists Management.
